Yes, but only the prosecutor or a judge can drop them, not the person who called the police. The prosecutor, usually the district attorney under Government Code 26500, decides whether to file and pursue a domestic violence case, and a judge can dismiss a case in furtherance of justice under Penal Code 1385.
Can the person who called the police drop the charges?
No. The district attorney decides whether a domestic violence case is filed and pursued, and the person who called the police does not make that decision.
"The public prosecutor shall attend the courts, and within his or her discretion shall initiate and conduct on behalf of the people all prosecutions for public offenses." (Government Code section 26500)
An arrest is not a charge. After an arrest, the district attorney decides whether to file charges and whether to keep them going. The case is brought "on behalf of the people", not on behalf of the person who called. In some cities a city attorney prosecutes misdemeanors instead: state law lets a city attorney prosecute a misdemeanor committed in the city with the district attorney’s consent (Government Code 41803.5(a)). Where a city attorney has the case, that office makes these decisions. The firm’s answer on who prosecutes a Los Angeles case explains how that works there.
That person can speak up. At the scene, police must give a domestic violence victim a written notice that includes a statement that the victim "may ask the district attorney to file a criminal complaint" (Penal Code 13701(c)(9)(E)). That statement is about asking for a charge, not about withdrawing one.
Arrest is a separate step, and the statutes tie it to probable cause. For an assault or battery on a current or former spouse, partner or other listed family member, an officer may arrest without a warrant, even if the officer did not see it, when the officer has probable cause and makes the arrest as soon as probable cause arises (Penal Code 836(d)). Every law enforcement agency must also adopt a written policy that encourages arrest of domestic violence offenders when there is probable cause that an offense has been committed (Penal Code 13701(a) and (b)).
Who can dismiss a domestic violence case?
The district attorney can decline to file or ask to dismiss, and a judge can dismiss in furtherance of justice on the court’s own motion or the prosecutor’s application.
"The judge or magistrate may, either on motion of the court or upon the application of the prosecuting attorney, and in furtherance of justice, order an action to be dismissed." (Penal Code section 1385(a))
Section 1385(a) names two ways to start a dismissal under it: the court’s own motion or the prosecutor’s application. It does not list the reasons a judge may rely on, and the judge must state the reasons on the record.
At a preliminary hearing, the magistrate must dismiss the complaint if it appears that no public offense was committed, or that there is not sufficient cause to believe the defendant guilty (Penal Code 871).
| Who | What the law gives them | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Police | May arrest without a warrant on probable cause; written policy must encourage arrest when there is probable cause | Penal Code 836(d), 13701(b) |
| District attorney | Decides whether to file and pursue the case | Government Code 26500 |
| Judge | May dismiss in furtherance of justice, on the court’s motion or the prosecutor’s application | Penal Code 1385(a) |
| Magistrate at a preliminary hearing | Must dismiss if no public offense was committed or the cause is not sufficient | Penal Code 871 |
| Victim who called the police | May ask the district attorney to file a complaint; cannot be jailed for contempt for refusing to testify about the crime | Penal Code 13701(c)(9)(E); Code of Civil Procedure 1219(b) |
Who can do what in a California domestic violence case, and the statute that gives the power.
What if the person who called will not testify?
The district attorney still decides whether the case continues. A court may not jail a domestic violence victim for contempt for refusing to testify about the crime.
"Notwithstanding any other law, a court shall not imprison or otherwise confine or place in custody the victim of a sexual assault or domestic violence crime for contempt if the contempt consists of refusing to testify concerning that sexual assault or domestic violence crime." (Code of Civil Procedure section 1219(b))
That section limits jail for the contempt. It does not say the case must stop. Whether a case can go forward without the accuser on the stand depends on the other evidence and on the hearsay and confrontation rules, which the firm covers in Can a domestic violence case go forward if the accuser will not testify? If the accuser changes the account, that raises separate risks for the accuser: see Can you go to jail for recanting a statement in California?
Can I contact the accuser about dropping the case?
Not if a protective order bars contact. Trying to talk the person out of reporting, testifying or helping the prosecution can be a separate crime under Penal Code 136.1.
A criminal court can issue protective orders when it has good cause to believe a victim or witness has been, or is likely to be, harmed, intimidated or dissuaded. One kind of order says a person "shall have no communication whatsoever with a specified witness or a victim except through an attorney under reasonable restrictions that the court may impose" (Penal Code 136.2(a)(1)(D)). When the charge involves domestic violence, the court must consider issuing these orders on its own motion (Penal Code 136.2(e)(1)).
The order’s terms "remain enforceable, notwithstanding the acts of the parties, and may be changed only by order of the court" (Penal Code 13710(b)). So the accuser’s agreement to contact does not change the order.
Trying to stop a victim or witness from cooperating is also a crime on its own. Penal Code 136.1(a) covers knowingly and maliciously preventing or dissuading a witness or victim from attending or giving testimony, or attempting to. Subdivision (b) covers attempting to prevent or dissuade a victim or witness from making a report, from causing a complaint to be sought and prosecuted, or from assisting in the prosecution. An attempt counts even if it fails, and it is no defense that no one was injured or actually intimidated (136.1(d)).
The firm’s answers on PC 136.1 witness intimidation and on what peaceful contact allows under a criminal protective order go further. Read the order itself, and ask a lawyer before any contact about the case.
Related questions
- Can a domestic violence case go forward if the accuser will not testify?
- Does the restraining order against me end if my criminal case is dismissed?
- Can I get diversion for a domestic violence charge in California?
- Is domestic violence a felony in California?
Frequently asked questions
Is diversion an option instead of a dismissal?
Not the general misdemeanor diversion. Penal Code 1001.95(e) bars that diversion for any offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Family Code 6211 or Penal Code 13700(b). The firm’s answer on diversion in a domestic violence case covers what else a judge may consider.
What if the case is not dismissed and I am convicted?
If probation is granted for a crime against a person covered by Family Code 6211, Penal Code 1203.097(a) requires at least 36 months of probation, a criminal protective order and a batterer’s program of at least one year. For the charge levels, see the firm’s answer on whether domestic violence is a felony.
Does a protective order end if the case is dismissed?
It depends on which order it is. A criminal court order and a civil family court order end in different ways. The firm’s answer on restraining orders after a dismissal explains each.
Talk to a lawyer
The Law Offices of David S. Chesley defend domestic violence charges across California (see the firm’s domestic violence lawyer page).
The firm offers a free consultation, is available 24/7, and offers payment plans. Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.
This page is general information, not legal advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.