Generally no. The Ninth Circuit has held that an obscene gesture and profanities aimed at a police officer are protected by the First Amendment, and Penal Code 415(3) reaches only "offensive words in a public place which are inherently likely to provoke an immediate violent reaction". A gesture can still accompany conduct charged under another section.

Is flipping off a police officer protected by the First Amendment?

In Duran v. City of Douglas, the Ninth Circuit held that an obscene gesture and profanities aimed at an officer fell "squarely within the protective umbrella of the First Amendment".

In Duran v. City of Douglas (9th Cir. 1990) 904 F.2d 1372, a passenger "directed a series of expletives and an obscene hand gesture" at a police officer, who stopped the car and arrested him. The court wrote that "disgraceful as Duran's behavior may have been, it was not illegal; criticism of the police is not a crime". It added that "Inarticulate and crude as Duran's conduct may have been, it represented an expression of disapproval toward a police officer" that "fell squarely within the protective umbrella of the First Amendment".

Duran applied a principle the Supreme Court stated in City of Houston v. Hill (1987) 482 U.S. 451: "the First Amendment protects a significant amount of verbal criticism and challenge directed at police officers". Duran was a federal civil rights case from Arizona about one officer's stop and arrest. The Ninth Circuit covers California, but this page does not predict how a court would treat any particular gesture.

Does a California statute make the gesture a crime?

Penal Code 415(3) covers only "offensive words in a public place which are inherently likely to provoke an immediate violent reaction", not every insult or gesture.

Section 415 provides a penalty of up to 90 days in county jail, a fine of up to $400, or both, for three kinds of conduct. Penal Code 19.8 also lists Section 415 among the offenses that can be handled as infractions, with a fine of up to $250. Under Section 17(d), that happens if the prosecutor files the charge as an infraction and the defendant does not elect a misdemeanor case, or if the court so decides with the defendant's consent. Subdivision (1) is unlawfully fighting in a public place or challenging another person to fight there. Subdivision (2) is maliciously and willfully disturbing another person "by loud and unreasonable noise". Subdivision (3) is using "offensive words in a public place which are inherently likely to provoke an immediate violent reaction". The text of Section 415 does not mention gestures.

The idea behind subdivision (3) comes from "fighting words" cases. In Cohen v. California (1971) 403 U.S. 15, the Supreme Court described them as "those personally abusive epithets which, when addressed to the ordinary citizen, are, as a matter of common knowledge, inherently likely to provoke violent reaction". Cohen reversed a conviction under Section 415, as it was then worded, of a man who wore a jacket bearing a four-letter expletive in a courthouse corridor. The Court wrote that "absent a more particularized and compelling reason for its actions", the State may not, "consistently with the First and Fourteenth Amendments, make the simple public display here involved of this single four-letter expletive a criminal offense". The "offensive conduct" clause at issue in Cohen is not in the current text of Section 415.

In Houston v. Hill, the Court noted a Justice's suggestion that the fighting words exception "might require a narrower application in cases involving words addressed to a police officer". California's jury instruction for Section 415(3), CALCRIM No. 2690, asks whether the words were "reasonably likely to provoke someone else to react violently" and whether there was "a clear and present danger that the other person will immediately erupt into violence", considering "all the circumstances in which the statement was made and the person to whom the statement was addressed". The instruction's Related Issues note, quoting In re Alejandro G. (1995) 37 Cal.App.4th 44, says that the addressee's being a police officer "is merely one factor to be considered along with the other circumstances". This page does not answer whether Section 415(3) can reach a gesture at all, or whether a particular gesture was inherently likely to provoke an immediate violent reaction; the second question turns on the circumstances.

Can a gesture become part of a charge?

Section 148(a)(1) punishes willfully resisting, delaying or obstructing an officer, so a gesture accompanied by other conduct can lead to a charge on that other conduct.

Section 148(a)(1) applies to someone who "willfully resists, delays, or obstructs any public officer, peace officer" in the discharge of a duty. It describes what a person does to the officer's work and does not mention insults or gestures. If an encounter also includes other conduct that is alleged to resist, delay or obstruct, a charge would rest on that other conduct, and the facts of the whole encounter matter. The firm's page on obstructing a police officer covers the offense.

Setting matters too. In Duran, the officer argued that he believed the conduct was disorderly. The court rejected that because the car was traveling late at night on a deserted road, so the conduct "could not have disturbed the peace or incited a riot".

Can an officer stop or punish someone for the gesture?

Duran says police "may not exercise the awesome power at their disposal to punish individuals for conduct that is not merely lawful, but protected by the First Amendment".

The Duran court wrote that "police, no less than anyone else, may resent having obscene words and gestures directed at them", but that they "may not exercise the awesome power at their disposal to punish individuals for conduct that is not merely lawful, but protected by the First Amendment". It added that "No matter how peculiar, abrasive, unruly or distasteful a person's conduct may be, it cannot justify a police stop unless it suggests that some specific crime has been, or is about to be, committed, or that there is an imminent danger to persons or property".

A stop or arrest for a different reason, such as a traffic violation, is a different question. Duran held that "the stop and detention was illegal" because nothing gave the officer cause, and it left for further proceedings whether he acted in retaliation. A person who believes an officer acted in retaliation can ask a lawyer to review the facts.

Frequently asked questions

Is cursing at a police officer illegal in California?

Duran involved profanities as well as a gesture, and the court wrote that "criticism of the police is not a crime". Section 415(3) reaches "offensive words in a public place which are inherently likely to provoke an immediate violent reaction". Whether particular words meet that test depends on the circumstances, and a lawyer can review them.

Does the First Amendment protect everything a person does toward an officer?

No. The cases on this page concern expressions of disapproval. Section 148(a)(1) separately covers a person who "willfully resists, delays, or obstructs" an officer, and Section 415(3) covers words "inherently likely to provoke an immediate violent reaction". A lawyer can review where particular facts fall.

Does Duran decide every case about gestures toward police?

No. Duran was a federal civil rights case about one officer's stop and arrest in Arizona. It is a Ninth Circuit decision, and the Ninth Circuit covers California, but each case turns on its own facts.

Talk to a lawyer

The Law Offices of David S. Chesley defend criminal charges across California (see the firm's criminal defense lawyer page).

The firm offers a free consultation, is available 24/7, and offers payment plans. Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.

This page is general information, not legal advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.