Sometimes: no California statute bans spanking by name, but there are limits. Penal Code 273d makes it a felony to willfully inflict on a child "any cruel or inhuman corporal punishment or an injury resulting in a traumatic condition". A parent's reasonable discipline is a defense under CALCRIM No. 3405.

What do the child abuse statutes prohibit?

Penal Code 273d covers willfully inflicting cruel or inhuman corporal punishment, or an injury resulting in a traumatic condition, on a child; Section 273a(b) covers unjustifiable physical pain.

Penal Code 273d(a) applies to a person who "willfully inflicts upon a child any cruel or inhuman corporal punishment or an injury resulting in a traumatic condition". The section does not define "cruel or inhuman". CALCRIM No. 822, the Judicial Council's jury instruction for Section 273d(a), says the People must prove that the defendant willfully inflicted cruel or inhuman physical punishment or an injury on a child, and that the punishment or injury "caused a traumatic physical condition to the child". It defines that condition: "A traumatic physical condition is a wound or other bodily injury, whether minor or serious, caused by the direct application of physical force." It says a person acts willfully when the person acts "willingly or on purpose", and that a child is "any person under the age of 18 years".

Section 273a(b) is a separate misdemeanor. It covers a person who, "under circumstances or conditions other than those likely to produce great bodily harm or death, willfully causes or permits any child to suffer, or inflicts thereon unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering", along with other conduct the subdivision lists, and says that person "is guilty of a misdemeanor". CALCRIM No. 823 defines unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering as pain or suffering that "is not reasonably necessary or is excessive under the circumstances".

The firm's page on child abuse charges covers Penal Code 273d from the defense side.

Does a parent have a right to use reasonable discipline?

Yes, within limits. CALCRIM No. 3405 says a parent is not guilty if the force used to discipline a child was justifiable: necessary under the circumstances and reasonable.

CALCRIM No. 3405, titled "Parental Right to Punish a Child", says that a parent, a guardian or another person legally permitted to discipline the child is not guilty of the charged crime if that person used justifiable physical force to discipline a child. The force is justifiable "if a reasonable person would find that punishment was necessary under the circumstances" and that the force used was reasonable. "The People must prove beyond a reasonable doubt" that the force used was not justifiable. The instruction's bench notes say: "The court has a sua sponte duty to instruct on the right of a parent to discipline a child."

The instructions for the two charges build the defense into their elements. CALCRIM No. 822 adds, when the parental right is at issue, that the defendant "was not reasonably disciplining a child". CALCRIM No. 823 adds that "The defendant did not act while reasonably disciplining a child." The authority list for CALCRIM No. 822 cites People v. Thomas (1976) 65 Cal.App.3d 854, with the note "victim’s size and age relevant to reasonableness of corporal punishment".

The commentary to CALCRIM No. 822 has a short entry headed "Spanking". It says: "It is not unlawful for a parent to spank a child for disciplinary purposes with an object other than the hand. The punishment, however, must be necessary and not excessive in relation to the individual circumstances." The entry cites a 1997 Attorney General opinion, 80 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 203. It is commentary, not a statute.

Education Code 44807 also refers to a parent's privilege. It says a teacher, vice principal, principal or other certificated employee of a school district "shall not be subject to criminal prosecution or criminal penalties" for the exercise, during the performance of the employee's duties, of "the same degree of physical control over a pupil that a parent would be legally privileged to exercise but which in no event shall exceed the amount of physical control reasonably necessary to maintain order, protect property, or protect the health and safety of pupils, or to maintain proper and appropriate conditions conducive to learning".

This page does not say whether any particular act is reasonable discipline. That depends on the facts.

What does California law say about spanking by name?

Welfare and Institutions Code 300(a) names it. Under that subdivision, serious physical harm excludes reasonable and age-appropriate spanking to the buttocks if there is no evidence of serious physical injury.

Welfare and Institutions Code 300 lists the situations in which a child "is within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court which may adjudge that person to be a dependent child of the court". Subdivision (a) covers a child who "has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian". The subdivision adds that serious physical harm "does not include reasonable and age-appropriate spanking to the buttocks if there is no evidence of serious physical injury".

That sentence opens with "For purposes of this subdivision", so it speaks to subdivision (a) of Section 300. By its words it does not reach the criminal statutes above.

What is the punishment under Penal Code 273d?

A felony that can become a misdemeanor: two, four or six years under Section 1170(h), or up to 364 days in county jail, a fine up to $6,000, or both.

Section 273d(a) says a person who violates it "is guilty of a felony and shall be punished by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 for two, four, or six years, or in a county jail for not more than one year, by a fine of up to six thousand dollars ($6,000), or by both that imprisonment and fine." Under Penal Code 18.5(a), an offense "punishable by imprisonment in a county jail up to or not exceeding one year" is punishable by a county jail term "not to exceed 364 days". Because Section 273d(a) also allows county jail or a fine, Penal Code 17(b) makes it "a misdemeanor for all purposes" in the cases it lists. They include a judgment imposing a punishment other than state prison or a Section 1170(h) term, and a court's declaration that the offense is a misdemeanor when or after it grants probation.

Subdivision (b) adds "a four-year enhancement for a prior conviction of that offense", subject to the 10-year period it describes. If probation is granted, subdivision (c) requires these minimum conditions:

  • "A mandatory minimum period of probation of 36 months";
  • "A criminal court protective order protecting the victim from further acts of violence or threats, and, if appropriate, residence exclusion or stay-away conditions";
  • "Successful completion of no less than one year of a child abuser’s treatment counseling program"; and
  • if the offense was committed while the defendant was under the influence of drugs or alcohol, abstaining from drugs and alcohol during probation and random drug testing.

The court "may waive any of the above minimum conditions of probation upon a finding that the condition would not be in the best interests of justice".

Does a spanking have to be reported as child abuse?

For mandated reporters, it depends on whether they know or reasonably suspect child abuse or neglect, which includes unlawful corporal punishment or injury as Section 11165.4 defines it.

Penal Code 11165.6 says that child abuse or neglect includes "unlawful corporal punishment or injury as defined in Section 11165.4". Section 11165.4 defines that term as "a situation where any person willfully inflicts upon any child any cruel or inhuman corporal punishment or injury resulting in a traumatic condition". It does not include reasonable and necessary force by public school staff to quell a disturbance, for self-defense or to obtain weapons or other dangerous objects, the physical control that Education Code 44807 authorizes, or an injury caused by reasonable and necessary force used by a peace officer acting within the course and scope of employment.

Under Section 11166(a), with exceptions in subdivision (d) and Section 11166.05, a mandated reporter "shall make a report to an agency specified in Section 11165.9 whenever the mandated reporter, in the mandated reporter’s professional capacity or within the scope of the mandated reporter’s employment, has knowledge of or observes a child whom the mandated reporter knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse or neglect". Reasonable suspicion "does not require certainty that child abuse or neglect has occurred".

Can teachers or school staff spank students?

Not in a public school. Education Code 49001 bars anyone employed by or engaged in one from inflicting corporal punishment on a pupil, and voids any rule that authorizes it.

Education Code 49001 says corporal punishment "means the willful infliction of, or willfully causing the infliction of, physical pain on a pupil". Subdivision (b) says "No person employed by or engaged in a public school shall inflict" corporal punishment on a pupil or cause it to be inflicted, and "Every resolution, bylaw, rule, ordinance, or other act or authority permitting or authorizing the infliction of corporal punishment upon a pupil attending a public school is void and unenforceable." The section carves out reasonable and necessary force to quell a disturbance threatening physical injury to persons or damage to property, for self-defense, or to obtain possession of weapons or other dangerous objects within the control of the pupil, and physical pain or discomfort caused by voluntary athletic competition or other recreational activity.

Frequently asked questions

Does Penal Code 273d apply only to parents?

No. Section 273d(a) applies to "Any person who willfully inflicts upon a child" the conduct it describes, and CALCRIM No. 822 defines a child as "any person under the age of 18 years". The discipline defense in CALCRIM No. 3405 names a parent, a guardian or another person legally permitted to discipline the child.

Does a spanking have to leave a mark to be a crime?

It depends on the statute. For Section 273d(a), CALCRIM No. 822 requires that the punishment or injury "caused a traumatic physical condition to the child", defined as a "wound or other bodily injury, whether minor or serious". Section 273a(b) speaks of "unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering", which CALCRIM No. 823 defines as pain or suffering that "is not reasonably necessary or is excessive under the circumstances".

Talk to a lawyer

The Law Offices of David S. Chesley represent people charged with child abuse and other violent offenses across California (see the firm's criminal defense lawyer page and its page on child abuse charges).

The firm offers a free consultation, is available 24/7, and offers payment plans. Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.

This page is general information, not legal advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.