Held to answer means a magistrate has found, after an examination, that a public offense has been committed and there is sufficient cause to believe the defendant is guilty. Penal Code 872(a) states the order, and Penal Code 871 states the opposite result, a dismissal. It is not a conviction.
What is an order holding a defendant to answer?
It is the magistrate's order after a preliminary examination that a public offense has been committed and there is sufficient cause to believe the defendant is guilty of it.
Section 872(a) says that when "it appears from the examination that a public offense has been committed, and there is sufficient cause to believe that the defendant is guilty", the magistrate "shall make or indorse on the complaint an order, signed by him or her". The order ends with the words "I order that he or she be held to answer to the same". Section 739 describes the same step in other words: a defendant who "has been examined and committed, as provided in Section 872".
What does the magistrate have to find?
That a public offense has been committed and there is sufficient cause to believe the defendant is guilty. If either is missing, Penal Code 871 requires dismissal and discharge.
Section 871 covers the other result. If "it appears either that no public offense has been committed or that there is not sufficient cause to believe the defendant guilty of a public offense", the magistrate "shall order the complaint dismissed and the defendant to be discharged". Section 866(b) states the purpose of a preliminary examination: "to establish whether there exists probable cause to believe that the defendant has committed a felony". It adds that the examination "shall not be used for purposes of discovery". An order to hold a defendant to answer therefore rests on probable cause, not on a decision that the defendant is guilty.
Section 872(b) adds a rule on evidence. "Notwithstanding Section 1200 of the Evidence Code", the finding of probable cause "may be based in whole or in part" on the sworn testimony of "a law enforcement officer or honorably retired law enforcement officer" who relates out-of-court statements "offered for the truth of the matter asserted". The officer must have "five years of law enforcement experience" or have "completed a training course certified by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training" whose content includes "the investigation and reporting of cases and testifying at preliminary hearings". An honorably retired officer may relate only statements "made when the honorably retired officer was an active law enforcement officer".
What happens after a defendant is held to answer?
The district attorney must file an information in superior court within 15 days after the commitment, under Penal Code 739. Section 739 sets no date for the next court appearance.
Section 739 requires the district attorney to file an information "within 15 days after the commitment". The information may charge "the offense or offenses named in the order of commitment" or an offense "shown by the evidence taken before the magistrate to have been committed". The section sets no date for the next court appearance, so that date depends on the court's calendar, and any typical timeline is practice, not law. The firm's answers on what happens after a felony preliminary hearing and on adding a felony charge after the preliminary hearing cover the next steps.
A defendant held to answer can also move to set the information aside: under Penal Code 995(a)(2)(B), the court must set it aside on the defendant's motion if the defendant "had been committed without reasonable or probable cause".
A 2026 law, in effect from January 1, 2027, adds a step for later cases. AB 1917 (Stats. 2026, ch. 376) adds subdivision (c) to Penal Code 995, which begins "In cases where the defendant, on or after January 1, 2027, was held to answer on at least one felony count at the preliminary hearing". Before "filing an information reinstating an offense or offenses dismissed at the preliminary examination due to the lack of reasonable or probable cause", the district attorney "shall file a motion seeking leave to charge that offense or offenses". The act also adds "except as specified in subdivision (c) of Section 995" to Section 739. Under the new subdivision, the court may grant the motion only if it "finds that the offense has been committed and there is sufficient reasonable or probable cause to believe the defendant is guilty", and the district attorney must file it within the 15 days of Section 739. Once it is granted, a Section 995(a) motion alleging a lack of reasonable or probable cause "may not be filed to set aside any reinstated offense or offenses".
What happens if the defendant is not held to answer?
Under Penal Code 871, the magistrate orders the complaint dismissed and the defendant discharged. Penal Code 1387(a) then decides whether the charge can be filed again.
Section 871 says the magistrate "shall order the complaint dismissed and the defendant to be discharged". Penal Code 1387(a) makes such an order a bar to another prosecution of a felony only when the action "has been previously terminated" under one of the sections it lists, and it lists exceptions to that bar, such as "substantial new evidence" the prosecution could not have known with due diligence. The firm's answer on what happens after a felony preliminary hearing covers what a dismissal means for a later filing.
Related questions
- What happens after a California felony preliminary hearing?
- Preliminary Hearings
- What is a felony complaint, and how does a felony case start?
- Can prosecutors add a felony charge after the preliminary hearing?
Frequently asked questions
Does held to answer mean the defendant is guilty?
No. Section 872(a) requires "sufficient cause to believe that the defendant is guilty", and Section 866(b) states the purpose of a preliminary examination as "to establish whether there exists probable cause to believe that the defendant has committed a felony".
Can a hold rest on hearsay?
Within limits, yes. Section 872(b) allows the finding of probable cause to rest "in whole or in part upon the sworn testimony of" a qualified law enforcement officer relating out-of-court statements, "Notwithstanding Section 1200 of the Evidence Code".
Talk to a lawyer
The Law Offices of David S. Chesley defend criminal charges across California (see the firm's criminal defense lawyer page).
The firm offers a free consultation, is available 24/7, and offers payment plans. Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.
This page is general information, not legal advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.
