A pretrial conference is a court date after arraignment where the prosecutor and defense lawyer try to settle the case before trial, sometimes with the judge in the room. Nothing is decided about guilt unless the case is resolved there. If it is not, the case moves toward motions and trial.

What is a pretrial conference?

It is a court date set after arraignment so the lawyers can discuss ending the case without a trial. Courts also call it a settlement conference.

The state's self-help guide describes the stretch after an arraignment as a pretrial period. The two sides share information, called discovery. There are also court dates "to try to reach an agreement or make plans for trial." The judge generally sets one of those dates right after the arraignment, and the guide says it "may be a pretrial conference or a settlement conference." The judge may meet with the lawyers (California Courts, pretrial activities).

The Orange County Superior Court uses the plain label "Pre-Trial" for the same step in both misdemeanor and felony cases. It describes a conference of the prosecutor and the defense to discuss the possibility of disposing of a case before trial (Orange County Superior Court, appearing in criminal court). Names and calendars differ from court to court, so the notice you received controls the date, the department and the title.

Who has to attend a pretrial conference?

A misdemeanor-only defendant may usually appear through a lawyer. A felony defendant must attend, in person or remotely, unless a waiver is approved.

Penal Code section 977(a)(1) says a person charged with a misdemeanor only "may appear by counsel only," with exceptions in paragraphs (2) and (3). A misdemeanor involving domestic violence, or a violation of Penal Code 273.6, carries a presence requirement at arraignment and sentencing, plus any date the court sets for explaining the terms of a protective order. For a misdemeanor driving under the influence offense, the court can, in an appropriate case, order the defendant to be there for arraignment, for entering a plea or for sentencing.

For a felony, section 977(b)(1) requires physical presence at the arraignment and plea, at the preliminary hearing, while evidence is taken at trial, and at sentencing. At "all other proceedings," which includes a pretrial conference, the accused must be there physically or remotely unless the person waives that right with the court's leave and the lawyer's approval.

Whatever the statute allows, read the notice. If it says to appear, appear, and ask your lawyer before relying on a lawyer-only appearance.

What can happen at a pretrial conference?

The case can settle by plea agreement, be dismissed, or get new dates for motions or trial. Often the conference ends with a new date and no final result.

  • A plea agreement. The state's guide says one common way to settle is for the defendant to plead guilty or no contest in exchange for a certain sentence or for some charges to be dropped. The judge will typically impose the agreed sentence. If the judge will not, the agreement typically falls apart and the defendant can take back the plea (California Courts, sentencing).
  • An offer to think about. The defense lawyer must tell the defendant about any offer from the prosecutor, and whether to accept it is the defendant's decision (California Courts, pretrial activities). A lawyer can explain what an offer would mean for the record, and compare it with what the evidence shows.
  • New dates. If nothing settles, the next dates are set. In felony cases, Orange County's list names a trial setting conference, where the case gets a trial date and pretrial motions are set as needed.
  • A dismissal. See the next section.

For a felony that is moving toward trial, the firm's separate answer on the felony readiness conference covers what to check before that date. For plea talks in general, see the firm's page on plea negotiations.

Can a case be dismissed at a pretrial conference?

Yes. A judge can dismiss in furtherance of justice, acting alone or at the prosecutor's request. Charges can also be dropped in a settlement.

Penal Code section 1385(a) allows a judge or magistrate to dismiss a case in furtherance of justice. Either the court itself or the prosecuting attorney can start that, and the judge has to say the reasons out loud for the record. The state's guide also treats dismissal as one way a case can end before trial: if the sides do not agree "or the judge does not dismiss the charges," the case moves toward trial.

A conference is a place to ask for that result, not a promise of it. What a prosecutor agrees to depends on the evidence, the charge and the person's record. A dismissal can also follow a defense motion that a judge decides at a separate hearing, such as a motion to suppress evidence or, in a felony, a motion under Penal Code 995. The firm's page on how a case gets dismissed covers those routes. A dismissal also does not always close the matter for good. The firm's answer on dismissal without prejudice covers when charges can be refiled.

Can you go to jail at a pretrial conference?

It is a settlement date, not a trial. Custody can follow an accepted plea with jail time, a change in release terms, or a missed date and warrant.

Three situations matter:

  1. You accept a plea with jail time. The sentence in the agreement is the one the judge will typically impose, so ask before the date whether an offer includes custody and when it would start.
  2. The judge changes your release terms. Penal Code section 1289 covers a defendant who is out on bail in a case brought by indictment or information: for good cause shown, the court may raise or lower the amount, and an increase can mean actual custody unless the new amount is posted.
  3. You miss the date. Penal Code section 978.5(a) permits a bench warrant if the defendant skips a date the court required. The Orange County court lists possible results of a missed hearing: a warrant, a probation revocation where it applies, an added failure-to-appear charge and forfeiture of posted bail. The firm's failure to appear defense page covers that side.

The full picture, across every kind of hearing, is in the firm's answer on being taken into custody at a California court hearing.

How does a pretrial conference differ from other early court dates?

It follows the arraignment and precedes trial. Its purpose is settlement talks. The arraignment is for the plea, and a motion hearing is for a ruling.

Table: where the pretrial conference fits among the early court dates.

Court date What it is for Source
Arraignment The defendant is brought before the court to plead to the charges in the complaint Orange County Superior Court
Pretrial or settlement conference The lawyers discuss settling the case, and the judge may join California Courts, pretrial activities
Motion hearing A party asks the judge to rule on a legal issue, such as a motion to suppress evidence California Courts, pretrial activities
Preliminary hearing (felony only) The judge rules on whether the evidence is sufficient for the case to proceed California Courts, pretrial activities
Trial setting conference (felony) The case is given a trial date and pretrial motions are set as needed Orange County Superior Court

For the arraignment itself, see what happens at a California arraignment.

What should you do before a pretrial conference?

Read the notice, gather what your lawyer asked for, and decide in advance what questions to ask about the offer and the evidence.

  • Check the date, the department and whether you must attend in person.
  • Bring any proof your lawyer asked for, such as completed classes or counseling.
  • Ask what the discovery shows and what each offer would mean beyond jail time.
  • Keep the facts of the case for your lawyer. Do not discuss them in a hallway.

Frequently asked questions

Is a pretrial conference the same as a trial?

No. It is a meeting date for the lawyers, and sometimes the judge, to discuss settlement and plan the next steps. No jury is involved and no verdict is reached. If the case does not settle, it continues toward motions and trial.

Do I have to attend a misdemeanor pretrial conference?

Often a lawyer may go in your place when the case is a misdemeanor only (Penal Code 977(a)(1)), but domestic violence and driving under the influence charges have exceptions, and a court notice can say otherwise. Confirm with your lawyer before skipping.

Can a judge sentence me at a pretrial conference?

If you accept a plea agreement there, the judge will typically give the sentence that was agreed. Sentencing hearings are more common in felony cases. Ask your lawyer before the date whether an offer would be entered and sentenced the same day.

What happens if I miss a pretrial conference?

Under Penal Code 978.5(a), a judge can order your arrest through a bench warrant if you do not appear. The Orange County court also lists revoked probation, an added failure-to-appear charge and forfeited bail as possible results. Contact your lawyer or the court right away.

How many pretrial conferences will my case have?

There is no fixed number. The state's guide says the pretrial period includes court dates to reach an agreement or plan for trial, and that a felony case has more such dates after the information is filed.

Should I take the prosecutor's offer?

That is your decision (California Courts, pretrial activities). A lawyer can explain what the offer means for the record and other consequences, and compare it with the evidence before you answer.

Talk to a lawyer

The Law Offices of David S. Chesley offers a free consultation and is available 24/7 to review your next court date, any offer and the evidence in your case, with payment plans and Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.