Nothing happens automatically: the judge may continue the hearing, the prosecution may use other evidence, or the case may be dismissed. Penal Code 1050(e) allows a continuance "only upon a showing of good cause", and no section on this page makes an officer's absence a ground for dismissal by itself.
Can the judge postpone the hearing?
Yes, but only for good cause. Penal Code 1050(e) says neither "the convenience of the parties nor a stipulation of the parties is in and of itself good cause".
Section 1050(b) asks for written notice "at least two court days before the hearing sought to be continued", with "affidavits or declarations detailing specific facts showing that a continuance is necessary". Under subdivisions (c) and (d), a party that misses the notice can still ask, but if it cannot show good cause for the failure, "the motion for continuance shall not be granted". When the court decides whether good cause exists, it "shall consider the general convenience and prior commitments of all witnesses, including peace officers". The section also "is directory only and does not mandate dismissal of an action by its terms".
When does a time limit force a dismissal?
When a Section 1382 deadline passes without good cause or a general time waiver; for a misdemeanor, 30 days after arraignment or plea in custody, otherwise 45.
Penal Code 1382(a) says "The court, unless good cause to the contrary is shown, shall order the action to be dismissed" in the cases it lists. In a felony, the listed limit is 60 days from "the defendant's arraignment on an indictment or information". For "a defendant in a misdemeanor or infraction case", trial must start within "30 days after he or she is arraigned or enters his or her plea", whichever is later, if the defendant is in custody at that time, and "in all other cases, within 45 days", counted the same way. The section does not define good cause. The firm's page on a motion for speedy trial covers the motion.
Can the case go forward without the officer?
Sometimes, on other evidence. An officer's out-of-court statement offered for its truth is hearsay, and Evidence Code 1200(b) makes hearsay inadmissible "Except as provided by law".
Section 1200(a) defines hearsay as evidence of a statement "made other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing" that "is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated". An officer's written report is such a statement when it is offered for its truth, so the prosecution needs an exception or another witness to prove what the officer saw. Section 702(a) says, "Subject to Section 801", that testimony about a matter "is inadmissible unless he has personal knowledge of the matter". A witness who was not there generally lacks personal knowledge of what the arresting officer saw.
The Evidence Code has exceptions to the hearsay rule. Section 1280 covers a writing "made by and within the scope of duty of a public employee", "made at or near the time of the act, condition, or event", when the "sources of information and method and time of preparation were such as to indicate its trustworthiness". Whether an exception covers a particular report is for the judge. Evidence Code 1291 lifts the hearsay rule for testimony the officer gave at an earlier hearing if the officer is "unavailable as a witness" and the defendant had "the right and opportunity to cross-examine the declarant with an interest and motive similar to that which he has at the hearing". Evidence Code 240(a) lists the kinds of unavailability; for a witness who stays away, one is that the prosecution "has exercised reasonable diligence but has been unable to procure his or her attendance by the court's process". The firm's answer on business records in a criminal trial covers a different exception.
Felony preliminary hearings work differently. Penal Code 872(b) says "Notwithstanding Section 1200 of the Evidence Code", a probable cause finding may rest on an officer's sworn testimony "relating the statements of declarants made out of court offered for the truth of the matter asserted". The officer must have "five years of law enforcement experience" or have completed a training course that the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training certifies. The firm's answer on a missing prosecution witness at a preliminary hearing covers that stage.
Does the defendant have a right to confront the witnesses?
Yes. The Sixth Amendment gives an accused the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against him", and California's Constitution gives the same right in Article I, Section 15.
The Sixth Amendment applies "In all criminal prosecutions". Article I, Section 15 of the California Constitution gives the defendant the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against the defendant". In Crawford v. Washington (2004) 541 U.S. 36, 68, the Supreme Court wrote that for testimonial evidence "the Sixth Amendment demands what the common law required: unavailability and a prior opportunity for cross-examination". It said "testimonial" applies "at a minimum to prior testimony at a preliminary hearing, before a grand jury, or at a former trial; and to police interrogations". This page does not decide whether a particular report or statement is testimonial.
Can the judge dismiss for another reason?
Yes, in furtherance of justice. Penal Code 1385(a) lets the judge dismiss on the court's own motion or the prosecutor's application, and the reasons must be stated on the record.
Section 1385(a) lets a judge or magistrate order an action dismissed "in furtherance of justice", acting "either on motion of the court or upon the application of the prosecuting attorney". The judge must state the reasons: "The reasons for the dismissal shall be stated orally on the record." Subdivision (a) does not say what counts as furtherance of justice, and it does not mention an officer's absence.
Can the case be filed again after a dismissal?
Sometimes. Penal Code 1387 decides whether an order ending the case bars another prosecution for the same offense, and the answer depends on the charge and any earlier dismissals.
Section 1387(a) covers an order terminating an action under Sections 1381 to 1388, which the Legislature's table of contents groups as Chapter 8, "Dismissal of the Action for Want of Prosecution or Otherwise", or under Section 859b, 861, 871 or 995. Sections 1382 and 1385 fall in that chapter. Such an order "is a bar to any other prosecution for the same offense" if the case is "a misdemeanor not charged together with a felony". For a felony, or a misdemeanor charged with a felony, the bar applies when "the action has been previously terminated pursuant to this chapter, or Section 859b, 861, 871, or 995". The statute lists exceptions for those felony cases, such as a judge's finding that "substantial new evidence has been discovered by the prosecution" that due diligence would not have uncovered earlier. The firm's answer on refiling after a dismissal without prejudice covers them.
Related questions
- What if a prosecution witness misses my California preliminary hearing?
- Can charges be refiled after a dismissal without prejudice?
- Motion for Speedy Trial
Frequently asked questions
Does a time waiver change the deadline?
Yes. For a misdemeanor, Section 1382(a)(3) says an action "shall not be dismissed under this subdivision" if the defendant "enters a general waiver of the 30-day or 45-day trial requirement" or "requests or consents to the setting of a trial date beyond the 30-day or 45-day period". Without a general waiver, a trial set later by request or consent must start "on the date set for trial or within 10 days thereafter". A lawyer can check what was waived.
Can the officer be punished for not coming?
Penal Code 1331 says disobeying a subpoena "may be punished by the Court or magistrate as a contempt". Code of Civil Procedure 1218(a) allows a contempt fine "not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000)", imprisonment "not exceeding five days", or both. Section 1209(d) stays a sentence for a peace officer acting within the scope of employment who fails to comply with a duly issued subpoena "pending the filing within three judicial days of a petition for extraordinary relief".
Can the defense subpoena the arresting officer?
Yes. Penal Code 1326(a)(4) lets "The attorney of record for the defendant" issue a subpoena. Under Penal Code 1331, a witness who disobeys a subpoena issued on the defendant's part, "unless he show good cause for his nonattendance", is "liable to the defendant in the sum of one hundred dollars". Penal Code 1328(c) allows service on the officer personally, on the officer's immediate superior or designated agent (two copies), or electronically where local agencies agree.
Talk to a lawyer
The Law Offices of David S. Chesley defend criminal charges across California (see the firm's criminal defense lawyer page).
The firm offers a free consultation, is available 24/7, and offers payment plans. Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.
This page is general information, not legal advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.
