Entrapment is a defense that applies when a law enforcement officer's conduct would cause a normally law-abiding person to commit the crime. In California the defendant must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence (CALCRIM 3408). A person who was only given an opportunity to commit a crime was not entrapped.

What counts as entrapment in California?

CALCRIM No. 3408 says a person is entrapped if an officer, or an officer's agent, engaged in conduct that would cause a normally law-abiding person to commit the crime.

No section of the California codes defines entrapment as a defense. The Judicial Council's jury instruction states the rule and lists People v. Barraza (1979) 23 Cal.3d 675 among its authorities for the instructional requirements. The instruction gives examples of conduct on each side of the line.

Conduct the instruction gives as examples of entrapment Conduct the instruction says is not entrapment
"badgering, persuasion by flattery or coaxing, repeated and insistent requests, or an appeal to friendship or sympathy" An officer who "simply gave the defendant an opportunity to commit the crime"
Conduct that would make the crime "unusually attractive", such as assuring the person that the act is not illegal or would go undetected, or "an offer of extraordinary benefit" An officer who "merely tried to gain the defendant's confidence through reasonable and restrained steps"

Examples from CALCRIM No. 3408. The instruction says entrapment "might include" the first-column conduct, so the list is not complete.

Who has to prove entrapment?

The defendant has the burden of proving entrapment by a preponderance of the evidence. The instruction says that means it is more likely than not that the defendant was entrapped.

The instruction adds: "This is a different standard from proof beyond a reasonable doubt." If the defendant proves entrapment, the jury is told "you must find" the defendant not guilty of the charged crime. The instruction cites People v. Barraza (1979) 23 Cal.3d 675, page 691, footnote 6, among its authorities for the burden of proof.

The bench notes say the court must instruct on the defense "when the defendant requests it and there is substantial evidence supporting the defense." Substantial evidence "means evidence of entrapment, which, if believed, would be sufficient for a reasonable jury to find that the defendant has shown the defense to be more likely than not."

What does the jury consider?

The jury focuses on the officer's conduct and asks what a normally law-abiding person would have done. It is told not to consider the defendant's predisposition.

The instruction tells jurors to "focus primarily on the conduct of the officer" and to ask whether that conduct "was likely to cause a normally law-abiding person to commit this crime". Jurors also consider other relevant circumstances:

  • events that happened before the crime
  • the defendant's responses to the officer's urging
  • the seriousness of the crime
  • how difficult it would have been for officers to discover that the crime had been committed

The instruction then says: "Do not consider the defendant's particular intentions or character, or whether the defendant had a predisposition to commit the crime."

Can I claim entrapment and still deny the charge?

Yes. The Related Issues notes to CALCRIM No. 3408 say a defendant may assert entrapment and still deny guilt, citing People v. Perez (1965) 62 Cal.2d 769.

The notes quote Perez: "it does not follow that the defendant must admit guilt to establish the defense." They list this under "Multiple Defenses Permitted".

Are stings and decoys entrapment?

Not by themselves. CALCRIM No. 3408's Related Issues notes say "ruses, stings, and decoys" to expose illicit activity are not entrapment if no pressure or overbearing conduct is used.

The notes say the use of those methods "does not constitute entrapment, as long as no pressure or overbearing conduct is employed by the decoy." Its example is a case about "underage, but mature-looking, decoys to expose unlawful sales of alcoholic beverages to minors". It adds that the conduct of an unwitting decoy "may also constitute sufficient badgering, cajoling, or importuning that entitles the defendant to an entrapment instruction", citing a federal court of appeals decision, Bradley v. Duncan (9th Cir. 2002) 315 F.3d 1091. The firm's answer on buying alcohol for a minor outside a store describes one such operation.

Frequently asked questions

Who counts as an officer's agent?

The instruction covers the conduct of a law enforcement officer or the officer's agent. It defines an agent as "a person who does something at the request, suggestion, or direction of an officer", and says "It is not necessary that the agent know the officer's true identity".

Does repeated asking by an officer always make it entrapment?

No. The instruction lists "repeated and insistent requests" as an example of conduct that might be entrapment. The jury still decides whether the officer's conduct "was likely to cause a normally law-abiding person to commit this crime," looking at the circumstances the instruction lists.

What if the officer pretended to be my accomplice?

CALCRIM No. 3409 is a separate instruction. It says that when an officer, "while acting for a law enforcement purpose," pretends to be an accomplice of a defendant, no act done by the officer "may be attributed to the defendant or held against the defendant". The exception is an act the defendant directed the officer to do, using his or her independent will. The bench notes say to give it "on request if supported by the evidence."

Talk to a lawyer

The Law Offices of David S. Chesley defend criminal cases across California (see the firm's criminal defense lawyer page and its pages on sale of a controlled substance and solicitation to commit murder).

The firm offers a free consultation, is available 24/7, and offers payment plans. Se habla español. Call (800) 755-5174 or request a free consultation online.

This page is general information, not legal advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.