A criminal defense attorney represents a person suspected or accused of a crime. In California that means advising you about your rights, including before police questioning, seeking your release, getting and testing the prosecution's evidence, filing motions, negotiating with the prosecutor, trying the case, and handling sentencing and appeals. You keep certain decisions, such as whether to plead guilty, testify or waive a jury.

Our law firm has been featured on

Fox NewsNBC NewsTIMEThe Wall Street JournalCBSThe New York TimesABCUnivisionLos Angeles TimesCNNMSNBC

David Chesley in the news

Select a photo to enlarge

For a broader look at California criminal defense representation, see the firm's Criminal Defense Lawyer page.

What does a criminal defense attorney do at each stage of a case?

The work changes as a case moves from investigation to court to sentencing; this table shows each step and the law behind it.

StageWhat the defense attorney doesLaw that applies
Before charges are filedAdvises you about questioning and searches, and can present information to the prosecutor before a filing decisionFifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination
ArraignmentStands with you as the charge is read, helps you enter a plea, and asks for release on your own recognizance or lower bailPenal Code 858(a), 1270(a), 1275
DiscoveryReceives the prosecution's evidence, including defendants' and witnesses' statements and any exculpatory evidence, and reviews it with youPenal Code 1054.1
Investigation and motionsInterviews witnesses, gathers records, and files motions, such as a motion to suppress evidence from an unreasonable search or seizurePenal Code 1538.5
Plea negotiationsNegotiates with the prosecutor and gives accurate and affirmative advice about the immigration consequences of any proposed pleaPenal Code 1016.3(a)
TrialConfronts and cross-examines the prosecution's witnesses, presents defense witnesses, and holds the state to proof beyond a reasonable doubtPenal Code 686, 1096
Sentencing and afterArgues for an appropriate sentence, then can pursue an appeal or record relief, such as dismissal after probationPenal Code 1203.4

The firm's guide to discovery and evidence review explains the evidence-exchange stage in more detail.

Which decisions belong to you, not your attorney?

Whether to plead guilty, waive a jury trial, testify and forgo an appeal are your decisions; the U.S. Supreme Court calls trial management "the lawyer's province" but says some decisions are "reserved for the client."

DecisionWho makes it
Whether to plead guiltyYou
Whether to waive a jury trialYou
Whether to testify in your own defenseYou
Whether to forgo an appealYou
Whether the defense will maintain your innocenceYou
Which arguments to pursueYour attorney
Which evidentiary objections to raiseYour attorney
What agreements to make about admitting evidenceYour attorney

In McCoy v. Louisiana (2018), the Court held that the choice to make innocence the objective of the defense also belongs to the client. California adds a duty to communicate: an attorney must respond promptly to reasonable status questions and keep you reasonably informed of significant developments (Business and Professions Code 6068(m)).

Is what you tell a criminal defense attorney confidential?

Yes, with narrow exceptions: you hold a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent others from disclosing, a confidential communication with your lawyer (Evidence Code 954), and the lawyer has a separate duty to "maintain inviolate the confidence" of a client (Business and Professions Code 6068(e)(1)).

A confidential communication includes the lawyer's legal opinion and advice, and it can still qualify when shared with people present to further your interest in the consultation or with those to whom disclosure is reasonably necessary for its purpose (Evidence Code 952). Section 6068(e)(2) states an exception to the duty of confidentiality: a lawyer may, but is not required to, reveal information the lawyer reasonably believes necessary to prevent a criminal act likely to result in death or substantial bodily harm. See the firm's answer on when attorney-client privilege does not apply.

Does a public defender do the same job as a private defense attorney?

Yes: a public defender is a defense attorney appointed for someone who cannot afford one, and state law requires the office to defend at all stages of the proceedings, including the preliminary examination (Government Code 27706(a)).

If you appear for arraignment without a lawyer, the court must tell you of your right to counsel and assign counsel if you want one and cannot afford it (Penal Code 987(a)). The differences lie in cost, choice and timing, which the firm covers in its comparison of a public defender and a private attorney.

What can a criminal defense attorney not do?

A defense attorney cannot mislead the court, cannot reveal your secrets outside narrow exceptions, cannot make your reserved decisions for you, and does not control whether charges are filed.

  • Mislead the judge: an attorney must use only means "consistent with truth" and must never seek to mislead a judge "by an artifice or false statement of fact or law" (section 6068(d)).
  • Share certain discovery with you: an attorney may not disclose a victim's or witness's personal identifying information, other than the name, to a defendant or the defendant's family without a court order after a hearing and good cause (Penal Code 1054.2(a)(1)).
  • Decide whether you are charged: except as otherwise provided by law, the district attorney is the public prosecutor and decides, within his or her discretion, which prosecutions to bring (Government Code 26500).
  • Decide the case: the judge or jury decides guilt, and the prosecution bears the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt (Penal Code 1096).

When should a criminal defense attorney get involved?

An attorney can help from the first contact with investigators through the end of the case, and at arraignment the court must assign counsel to anyone who wants a lawyer and cannot afford one (Penal Code 987(a)).

After an arrest, any California attorney may visit the person in custody at the request of the person or a relative, and an officer who willfully refuses that visit is guilty of a misdemeanor (Penal Code 825(b)). Once you have a lawyer, prosecutors deal with the lawyer: the San Diego County District Attorney's contact page, for example, notes that the Rules of Professional Conduct bar it from communicating directly with a represented defendant about the case. If you are getting ready to meet an attorney, the firm's guide on preparing for a criminal defense consultation can help.

Frequently asked questions

Can a defense attorney represent someone who is guilty?

Yes. California's rule that attorneys pursue only actions that appear "legal or just" expressly excepts "the defense of a person charged with a public offense" (section 6068(c)), and the state must still prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The San Diego County Public Defender puts it plainly: "A defense lawyer's belief in a client's guilt or innocence is totally irrelevant."

Do I need a defense attorney for a misdemeanor?

You have the right to one. A misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in county jail is capped at 364 days (Penal Code 18.5), and the court appoints counsel in a misdemeanor case for someone who cannot afford it when that is necessary for an adequate and effective defense (Penal Code 987.2(i)). In a misdemeanor case your lawyer can also appear for you, except in some domestic violence and DUI situations (Penal Code 977(a)).

Can I represent myself?

Yes. In Faretta v. California (1975), the U.S. Supreme Court held that a defendant in a state criminal trial may defend himself or herself without counsel when he or she voluntarily and intelligently chooses to do so. The Orange County Superior Court's self-help page cautions that because the consequences can be severe, it is best to have a lawyer.

Will my attorney tell my family about my case?

Not without your permission, because the duty of confidentiality runs to you as the client (section 6068(e)(1)). Having family in the room can affect whether a conversation stays privileged, depending on whether they are there to further your interest (Evidence Code 952).

Can a defense attorney be with me during police questioning?

You can ask for one. The Orange County Public Defender's FAQ advises stating clearly that you want an attorney present before and during any questioning, and repeating the request and otherwise staying silent if questioning continues.