DUI Alcohol: California Vehicle Code 23152
Defense Lawyers in Los Angeles Protecting the Rights of People Accused of Drunk Driving
Drunk driving is a serious problem, and we all want safer streets for families and our communities. That said, people make mistakes from time to time. Maybe you shouldn’t have had that last drink before leaving the party, or maybe you were called away earlier than expected due to an emergency. In some cases, overzealous policing results in false accusations of drunk driving. This can occur when police forget that drunk driving is against the law and that responsible adults are allowed to have a glass or two of wine or beer with dinner before driving home. Still, in others, the police mistake issues related to a medical condition as signs of intoxication, resulting in unfounded criminal charges.
We all know that drunk driving is against the law. Unfortunately for those facing drunk driving charges, the law is actually somewhat complicated. There is the “subjective” standard found in California Vehicle Code Section 23152(a), which prohibits any person from driving a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol. Section 23152(b),(d) and (e) prohibit driving a vehicle with a specific blood alcohol content (BAC):
- It prohibits driving any person from driving any vehicle with a BAC of 0.08 or greater.
- It prohibits any person from driving a commercial vehicle or driving a private vehicle with a paying passenger (e.g. Uber or Lyft) with a BAC of 0.04 or greater.
Regardless of the code section under which you are charged, you are facing serious legal penalties. For this reason, if you’ve been arrested for DUI in any capacity, you should contact a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer as soon as you can.
What’s the Difference?
Under the subjective standard of 23152(a), the prosecution does not need to prove that you had a specific BAC in order for you to be convicted - they just need to prove that you under the influence.
In order to prove that you were under the influence, the prosecution will rely on the testimony of the arresting officer. The officer will likely first testify to the behavior that led him or her to pull you over, such as:
- Failure to obey traffic signs;
- Weaving or otherwise driving erratically;
- Violation of various traffic laws.
From there, the officer will testify to your behavior during the traffic stop that led to your being charged with DUI. Here are some examples of the facts that the prosecution will want the officer to testify to:
- There was an odor of alcohol emanating from the vehicle;
- Your speech was slurred;
- Your eyes were red and watering;
- You were irrational or incoherent;
- You were uncooperative or even belligerent.
If field sobriety tests were administered, the prosecution will want the officer to testify that you failed the tests given.
The point here is that you can be convicted of DUI if they can prove that you were under the influence of alcohol, even if they can’t prove you had the requisite BAC. To be clear, the prosecution may want to introduce evidence regarding your BAC to support their case, but technically speaking, it isn’t required for them to do so.
Potential Penalties
First-time DUIs are typically a misdemeanor, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t take these charges seriously - it’s still a criminal conviction on your record with the potential for jail time and serious fines. In addition, a criminal conviction can harm your reputation and even make it hard to find a job. The potential consequences get even more serious if (1) you have prior DUIs on your record; and/or (2) someone was injured as a result of your driving under the influence. The number of prior convictions and the severity of the injuries will lead to harsher penalties. Below is a chart that summarizes the potential penalties you may be facing:
| Offense | Jail | Fine | Driver’s License |
| 1st offense - misdemeanor | Up to 6 months in county jail | Up to $1,000 | Suspended for 6-10 months, but driver is eligible for a restricted license |
| 2nd offense - misdemeanor | Up to 364 days in county jail | Up to $1,000 | Suspended for two years; driver is eligible for an ignition interlock restricted license without a waiting period (after 12 months in a drugs-only case) |
| 3rd offense - misdemeanor | Minimum 120 days up to 364 days in county jail | Up to $1,000 | Revoked for three years; driver is eligible for an ignition interlock restricted license without a waiting period (after 12 months in a drugs-only case) |
| DUI with injury - misdemeanor | Minimum 90 days to 364 days in county jail | Up to $5,000 plus restitution to injured parties | 1 to 3 years |
| DUI with injury - felony | 16 months to 16 years in state prison | $390-$5,000, plus restitution to injured parties | One to five years, depending on priors |
| Felony DUI (charged when you have 4 or more DUI convictions within a ten year period) | 16 months, two years, or 3 years in state prison | Up to $1,000 | Four years |
As you can see, the penalties become more severe with more convictions and injuries. In addition to the penalties listed above, you will also be ordered to attend DUI school for 3 months or as long as 30 months, depending on your case. It’s also important to note that some DUI charges carry total revocation of your license, with no eligibility to get a restricted license.
Aggravating Factors
In determining the penalties laid out above, there are certain aggravating factors that will affect the penalties imposed if you are convicted. Here are some of the most common aggravating factors:
- You were driving at an excessive speed;
- You were under the age of 21;
- You had a child under the age of 14 in the car;
- You caused an accident;
- You refused the breathalyzer test;
- You had a BAC of .15% or higher.
Defending Against DUI Charges
Facing DUI charges can be extremely intimidating, and you may be tempted to just admit everything, plead guilty, and hope for mercy from the judge. This is probably the worst possible strategy. An experienced DUI attorney in California can evaluate your case, spot the prosecution’s weaknesses, and get you a result that’s fair. Your Los Angeles criminal defense attorney may be able to raise legal defenses, potentially including the following:
- The breathalyzer or other testing equipment was not properly calibrated or otherwise functioning correctly.
- There were other factors that caused you to appear to be under the influence of alcohol, such as fatigue, prescription medications, or illness.
- The police didn’t administer the tests correctly, or the tests are inherently flawed.
- The police violated your constitutional rights or failed to follow the proper procedures during the arrest.
There are a number of other defenses that can be raised, but you needed someone who will aggressively contest every aspect of the prosecution’s case if you want to avoid suffering the harshest penalties available. Your California criminal defense attorney should work to get your charges dismissed altogether or at least reduced to something that’s fair.
In many cases, this means getting your DUI reduced to either a “dry reckless” or a “wet reckless.” A charge for dry reckless driving is a reckless driving charge without any alcohol involved. A “wet reckless” is more problematic - it is a charge only available as part of a plea bargain, and implies that there was alcohol was involved in the violation. While it carries reduced penalties (e.g. you may keep your license, avoid jail time, pay less in fines, etc.), it will be treated as a DUI conviction if you are charged with DUI in the future.
Contact a California DUI Defense Attorney Today to Schedule a Free Case Evaluation
If you or a loved when is facing DUI charges, you need a lawyer who will fight for your future. The criminal defense lawyers at The Law Offices of David S. Chesley offer our clients aggressive, experienced legal representation to get you a fair result. Call us at 800-755-5174 or email us today if you would like a free consultation.
Use the online contact form to ask about a consultation.
Does a High BAC Change the Penalties on a First DUI?
Yes. Under Vehicle Code Section 23578, if a person is convicted of DUI, the court must consider a blood alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, or a refusal to take the required breath or urine test, as a special factor in sentencing. The court weighs this factor when deciding the sentence itself, whether to grant probation, and what conditions to attach if probation is granted.
Section 23578 does not set one fixed extra fine or extra jail term by itself. In practice, a BAC at or above 0.15 percent commonly means the court orders the longer 6-month or 9-month first offender alcohol program instead of the standard 3-month program, on top of the other first-offense consequences described above. A reading of 0.20 percent or higher is not a separate numbered offense; for a first offense, though, it requires the 9-month program and a 10-month license suspension, and the measured result still has to come from a properly maintained and calibrated test. Ask about the exact BAC reading in the police report and how it affects the sentencing range before deciding how to proceed.




















































