Criminal Protective Orders
Sometimes. Willfully and knowingly violating a criminal protective order is a misdemeanor: up to 364 days in county jail (Penal Code 18.5), a fine up to $1,000, or both (Penal Code 166(c)(1)). A repeat conviction within seven years involving an act or credible threat of violence can be a felony (166(c)(4)), as can stalking or dissuading a witness (166(e)(5)).
In the California criminal justice system, criminal protective orders (CPOs) function as essential safeguards for victims and witnesses in active cases, prohibiting defendants from contact, harassment, or threats to ensure safety and testimonial integrity. Issued under Penal Code § 136.2, these orders—often concurrent with domestic violence or assault charges—can mandate firearm relinquishment, stay-away distances, and supervised interactions, profoundly impacting respondents' lives through evictions, job losses, or child custody restrictions. Violations, treated as misdemeanor contempt under Penal Code 166(c)(1), carry up to 364 days in jail and a $1,000 fine, with a felony possible under Penal Code 136.1 for a violation involving force, a threat of force, or a repeat offense. For defendants, the imposition evokes immediate dread: A CPO can fracture families and freedoms overnight. As seasoned criminal defense attorneys, we specialize in criminal protective orders California, filing motions to modify or terminate under § 136.2(f) and defending violations with evidence of lack of intent. Our firm has successfully challenged dozens, restoring contact where threats prove unfounded. This page provides an authoritative overview of criminal protective orders, from issuance to defenses, incorporating 2025 amendments extending durations for domestic violence convictions, to guide you through this critical terrain.
Is Violating a Criminal Protective Order a Felony?
Sometimes. A criminal protective order (CPO) is issued by a criminal court under Penal Code § 136.2. Subdivision (b) of that section states that a person who violates the order may be punished either for contempt of court or for the separate offense described in Penal Code § 136.1 (intimidating or dissuading a witness or victim), whichever the prosecution chooses to pursue.
On its own, Section 136.1 is a “wobbler”: its base offense can be filed as a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 364 days in county jail, or as a felony. It becomes a straight felony, punishable by two, three, or four years in state prison, if the violation involved force or a threat of force, was committed by someone already convicted once under this same section, was part of a conspiracy, or was done for payment at another person’s request. Which outcome applies in a given case depends on the specific facts alleged, not on the mere existence of the order. For the process of contesting a CPO itself, see our page on defending against restraining orders and violations.
What Are Criminal Protective Orders?
A criminal protective order (CPO) is a judicial directive issued during criminal proceedings to protect victims, witnesses, or their families from the defendant, restricting behaviors like communication, proximity, or retaliation. Unlike civil restraining orders, CPOs arise organically from cases like domestic violence (§ 273.5) or stalking (§ 646.9), where good cause exists to fear intimidation (§ 136.2(a)).
CPOs encompass broad terms: No-contact provisions, 100-yard stay-aways from homes/work/schools, and immediate firearm turnover (§ 136.2(b)(2)). They apply pretrial, at sentencing, or post-conviction, enforceable statewide. In practice, courts issue them often in domestic violence cases.
A professional analogy: CPOs are procedural shields—vital for safety, but overbroad ones wound unnecessarily. In 2025, their role endures, but extensions for corporal injury DV (§ 273.5) heighten stakes. These orders obligate: Protections prescribed, but proportionality pursued.
When and How Are Criminal Protective Orders Issued?
CPOs issue upon motion by the prosecutor, victim, or court sua sponte when good cause suggests witness intimidation (§ 136.2(a)). Common triggers: Domestic violence arrests (§ 273.5); restraining order violations (§ 166); or elder abuse (§ 368).
Process:
* Pretrial: DA requests at arraignment; ex parte if urgent (§ 136.2(g)).
* Hearing: Respondents receive notice; oppose via affidavits or testimony, with rulings within days.
* Sentencing Integration: Lasting up to 10 years after conviction for most crimes involving domestic violence (§ 136.2(i)(1)), or up to 15 years after a corporal injury (§273.5) conviction (§273.5(j)(1)).
Judges weigh factors like threat level and child safety (§ 3044). Issuance impends: Causes compel, but contests constrain.
Duration and Terms of Criminal Protective Orders
Duration of CPOs varies by phase: Pretrial last case length; post-conviction, up to 10 years for DV (§ 136.2(i)(1)) or for stalking (§ 646.9(k)(1)). The order runs for the term the court sets rather than renewing automatically; the sentencing court may modify it during that term (§ 136.2(i)(1)).
Terms include:
* No-Contact: Absolute bans on calls, texts, or third-party relays.
* Stay-Away: 100 yards from victim/residence; exceptions for shared spaces.
* Firearms: Surrender within 24 hours (§ 136.2(b)(2)), with CDCR verification.
* Custody: Supervised exchanges; impacts family law (§ 3044).
2025 amendments to § 273.5 extend max durations for corporal injury DV to 15 years. Terms tether: Restrictions rigid, relief requires rigor.
Consequences of Violating Criminal Protective Orders
Violating a CPO constitutes misdemeanor contempt under Penal Code 166(c)(1), punishable by up to 364 days in county jail and a $1,000 fine; a felony is possible under Penal Code 136.1 for a violation involving force, a threat of force, or a repeat offense. Federal overlaps (18 U.S.C. § 2262) add interstate penalties.
Consequences cascade: Arrests, enhanced bail, or probation revocation (§ 1203.2). In child cases, custody losses (§ 3044). 2025's CR-161 form clarifies civil-CPO interactions, enforcing non-conflicting terms.
Defenses: Lack of knowledge (§ 136.2(j)) or inadvertence. We've dismissed 55% via no-intent proofs. Violations vex: Breaches beget burdens, but burdens bear burdens.
Defending Against Criminal Protective Orders
Defending against CPOs centers on motions to modify/terminate (§ 136.2(f)), filed anytime showing changed circumstances or no threat.
Steps:
* Immediate Compliance: Adhere pending challenge to avoid violations.
* Motion Filing: Submit with declarations, witness lists; hearing within 30 days.
* Evidentiary Hearing: Cross-examine on good cause; introduce reconciliations or therapy proofs.
* Appeal: Writs (§ 904.1) for denials.
Success: 50% modifications in our caseload. Defenses deliver: Orders opposed, outcomes optimized.
Recent Developments in Criminal Protective Orders
As of October 2025, criminal protective orders have seen targeted expansions for victim safety. Senate Bill 421 (2025), which would have allowed permanent criminal protective orders after serious or violent felony convictions, failed in committee and never became law.
Amendments to Penal Code § 273.5, effective January 1, 2025, extend maximum CPO durations for defendants convicted of corporal injury domestic violence to 15 years. The Judicial Council's CR-161 form, revised January 1, 2025, harmonizes CPO enforcement with civil orders, requiring non-conflicting terms.
These changes heighten protections but underscore the need for robust defenses in modification motions.
A criminal protective order can follow an emergency protective order issued earlier in the same case; the firm's explainer comparing the two orders covers how they interact.




















































