California's "3 strike rule" is the Three Strikes Law, Penal Code sections 667(b) through (j) and 1170.12. One prior serious or violent felony (a "strike") doubles the sentence for a new felony conviction. Two or more prior strikes bring an indeterminate life term with a 25-year minimum, unless the current offense and record fit the second-strike exceptions Proposition 36 added in 2012.
What counts as a strike in California
A strike is a felony conviction for an offense defined as a "serious felony" in Penal Code section 1192.7(c) or a "violent felony" in Penal Code section 667.5(c). Section 1192.7(c) lists more than 40 offenses, including murder, voluntary manslaughter, rape, robbery, first degree burglary, carjacking, arson, kidnapping, criminal threats, and any felony in which the defendant personally used a firearm or a dangerous weapon or caused great bodily injury. Section 667.5(c) lists a separate but overlapping set of violent felonies, including murder, mayhem, specified sex offenses, and any felony punishable by death or life in prison. Many offenses appear on both lists, and a misdemeanor conviction is never a strike.
A strike must be pled in the current case and proved to the court, usually from the court record of the prior conviction. A prior conviction from another state counts as a strike only if it is for conduct that includes all the elements of a California serious or violent felony (Penal Code section 667(d)(2); section 1170.12(b)(2)). Whether a single prior act or case can supply more than one strike, and whether a specific out-of-state conviction qualifies, are fact-specific questions that come up often. See Can Two Prior Convictions From One Act Count as Two California Strikes? and Can an Out-of-State Conviction Count as a California Strike? Robbery and kidnapping are two examples that appear on both lists (see the firm's guide to penalties for robbery in California); assault with a deadly weapon is a serious felony under section 1192.7(c). Cases involving these charges, including assault, are handled within our violent offenses practice.
Juvenile adjudications can count as strikes
A juvenile adjudication, not only an adult conviction, can count as a strike. Under Penal Code section 667(d)(3) and section 1170.12(b)(3), a prior juvenile case counts only if the youth was 16 or older at the time of the offense, the offense is listed in Welfare and Institutions Code section 707(b) or otherwise qualifies as a serious or violent felony, the juvenile court found the youth a fit subject for juvenile court jurisdiction, and the youth was adjudged a ward of the court because of that offense. The California Supreme Court has held that counting a juvenile adjudication as a strike does not violate a defendant's right to a jury trial, because juvenile proceedings carry their own constitutional protections even without a jury (People v. Nguyen (2009) 46 Cal.4th 1007). See When a California Juvenile Adjudication Counts as a Prior Strike.
Second strike: a doubled sentence
If a defendant has one prior strike and is convicted of any new felony, the term for the new offense is doubled (Penal Code section 667(e)(1); section 1170.12(c)(1)). The new felony does not need to be serious or violent for the doubling to apply; a felony DUI conviction is one example (see the firm's felony DUI page), and the court cannot grant probation on the new offense. General probation and parole violation consequences are covered in the firm's probation and parole violations guide.
A striker's credits toward early release are also limited. Under Penal Code section 667(c)(5) and section 1170.12(a)(5), total credits cannot exceed one-fifth of the prison term and do not start building until the defendant reaches state prison. A separate rule, Penal Code section 2933.1, caps credits at 15 percent for anyone convicted of a violent felony listed in section 667.5(c), whether or not the case involves a strike.
Third strike: 25 years to life, with Proposition 36 exceptions
If a defendant has two or more prior strikes, the usual term for a new felony conviction is an indeterminate life sentence with a minimum of the greatest of 25 years, three times the term for the new offense, or the ordinary term for the new offense (Penal Code section 667(e)(2); section 1170.12(c)(2)).
Before November 2012, this 25-years-to-life term applied no matter how minor the new felony was. Proposition 36, the Three Strikes Reform Act of 2012, changed that rule. Now, if the new felony is not itself a serious or violent felony, a defendant with two or more prior strikes is instead sentenced as a second striker, with a doubled term, unless the prosecution pleads and proves one of several exceptions: the new offense is a controlled substance charge with an enhancement found true under Health and Safety Code sections 11370.4 or 11379.8, a specified sex offense, a crime in which the defendant used or was armed with a firearm or deadly weapon or intended great bodily injury, or the defendant has an earlier conviction for an offense such as a sexually violent offense, specified sex crimes against a young child, any homicide offense, solicitation to commit murder, or a crime punishable by life or death (Penal Code section 667(e)(2)(C); section 1170.12(c)(2)(C)).
Romero motions and Penal Code section 1385
A trial court has authority, on its own motion or on a defense motion, to strike a prior strike allegation "in furtherance of justice" under Penal Code section 1385. This is commonly called a Romero motion, after People v. Superior Court (Romero) (1996) 13 Cal.4th 497, in which the California Supreme Court held that the Three Strikes law did not remove a trial court's section 1385 authority to strike a prior strike allegation. The California Supreme Court later explained that a court may strike a strike only if the defendant falls outside the "spirit" of the Three Strikes law, after considering the nature of the current and prior offenses and the defendant's background, character, and prospects (People v. Williams (1998) 17 Cal.4th 148). A court cannot strike a prior strike out of sympathy alone, or to save court time, and it must state its reasons on the record. A Romero motion is argued at sentencing as part of sentencing advocacy built around the defendant's specific record and the current charge.
The firm's guide to a Romero motion in California explains how that request works.
Resentencing a third strike under Penal Code section 1170.126
Proposition 36 also created a resentencing process for people already serving a third-strike indeterminate life term for a current offense that is not serious or violent. Under Penal Code section 1170.126, an eligible inmate can petition the court that imposed the sentence for recall and resentencing to second-strike terms. An inmate is not eligible if the current offense fits one of the exceptions described above, or if an earlier conviction was for one of the most serious listed offenses. The deadline to petition was two years after the law's November 2012 effective date, though a court can accept a later petition for good cause. Even an eligible petitioner can be denied resentencing if the court finds, after considering the petitioner's criminal history, disciplinary record, and record of rehabilitation, that a new sentence would pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety. A new sentence under this process can never be longer than the original one. Courts have treated section 1170.126 as the resentencing remedy Proposition 36 created, including for people whose convictions were not yet final when the measure passed (People v. Yearwood (2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 161). Post-conviction relief options, including a section 1170.126 petition, depend on the inmate's specific record and current offense.
Proposition 36 of 2024 is a different law
Do not confuse the 2012 measure described above with Proposition 36 of November 2024, the Homelessness, Drug Addiction, and Theft Reduction Act. The 2024 measure changed penalties for repeat theft and drug offenses, including new "treatment-mandated felony" charges for some drug possession cases and higher penalties for some theft offenses, such as grand theft. It did not change the Three Strikes sentencing scheme in Penal Code sections 667(b) through (j) and 1170.12, or the resentencing process in section 1170.126, described above.
How a prior strike allegation is proved or disputed
The prosecution must plead each prior strike in the charging document and prove it beyond a reasonable doubt, usually with the court record of the prior conviction. A defendant can deny the allegation and require the prosecution to prove it, argue that the prior offense does not meet the legal definition of a serious or violent felony, or challenge a prior conviction that was obtained in violation of the defendant's constitutional rights. See How Is an Alleged Prior Strike Proved in a California Case?
For strategies used in pending three-strikes cases, see Three Strikes Defense Strategies.
For related background, see the firm's account of California's largest prison hunger strike. The Law Offices of David S. Chesley can be reached through its contact page.




















































