Elder Abuse

It can be either. Penal Code 368(b)(1) makes willfully abusing (physically or emotionally) or neglecting someone you know or reasonably should know is 65 or older, under circumstances likely to produce great bodily harm or death, a wobbler: two, three or four years in prison, or up to 364 days in jail (Penal Code 18.5). Otherwise, it is a misdemeanor.

Our law firm has been featured on

Fox NewsNBC NewsTIMEThe Wall Street JournalCBSThe New York TimesABCUnivisionLos Angeles TimesCNNMSNBC

David Chesley in the news

Select a photo to enlarge

To protect the aged person, California has enacted laws and penalties for anyone that is engaged in abuse of the elderly persons or dependent adults, declaring it as a criminal offense. The aged persons often have weak memory and movement which makes them vulnerable and therefore, the state has implemented laws that can protect these individuals. Elder abuse can occur in many ways, but physical and emotional abuse and financial exploitation are the common abuses that are reported to the authorities.

What is Elder Abuse?

Elder abuse is defined, charged and argued under PC 368. According to this statute

A person who ‘willfully’ inflicts pain, physical abuse, mental suffering or great bodily injury or ‘willfully’ allows the elder or dependent adult to remain in a situation that can cause pain, suffering or health damages, or who commits embezzles, fraud or forgery or falsely imprison the elderly is punishable by law.

Elements of PC 368

Like all criminal offenses, PC 368 has elements of the crime that the prosecutor must prove for conviction. The following are the elements of the crime of elder abuse.

  • The victim is 65 years old or older, and the defendant has or should have knowledge of it and;

For Misdemeanor:

  • The defendant intentionally inflicted physical pain or mental suffering to the elder person or;
  • The defendant acted with criminal negligence to subject the elderly to unreasonable physical pain or mental suffering that may have caused great bodily injury.

For Felony

  • The defendant intentionally inflicted physical pain or mental suffering to the elder person or;
  • The defendant acted with criminal negligence to subject the elderly to unreasonable physical pain or mental suffering that may have endangered the life or health of elderly.

For Financial Abuse

  • Or the defendant committed theft, embezzlement, forgery, or fraud or identity theft concerning property or personal information.
  • Or the defendant falsely imprisoned the elderly or dependent adult.

Examples of Elderly Abuse

While, the physical abuse is the most common types of abuse, the examples of elderly abuse include

  • Sexual abuse including inappropriate or unconsented touching
  • Physical abuse including hitting, slapping, kicking,
  • Emotional abuse including yelling, threatening, belittling, swearing or harassing
  • Criminal negligence including failure to provide medical treatment when in need, failure to provide basic needs such as food and cleanliness, allowing elderly in dangerous situations.
  • Financial abuse including forgery, fraud, theft or using financial information or personal information for monetary or non-monetary benefits.

However, many times these charges are falsely levied on caretakers whether at-home or at the boarding care without any reasonable or significant evidence. Several times, elder abuse charges are used by family members to get back to the other family members, to even the score, or to grab a share of gifts or inheritance. The weak memory of the purported victim or elderly further complicates the case.

If you are or your loved one is in trouble for facing the elder abuse charges, discuss the case with our experience defense attorney at (800) 755-5174. We provide free consultation to the defendants stuck in criminal charges. David S. Chesley’s Law office has its distinct name and reputation throughout the state of California for aggressive and successful defense. Our team of lawyers have worked as part of the legal system in the office of prosecutor, the law enforcement and court in the past which gives a competitive ability to prepare successful defense and present it in the court. We have the know-how of both sides of law which enables to effectively present your side of the story in the court leading to the dismissal of charges or reduced penalties.

Penalties for Elder Abuse

Elder abuse is a wobbler in Californian the law which means it can be charged as a misdemeanor or felony based on the circumstances of the case and previous convictions. The following are the penalties for elder abuse.

Elder Abuse: up to $6000 in fines, up to 364 days in county jail, up to four years in state or both fines and imprisonment.

Elder Abuse with great bodily injury: up to 3 years for the victim under 70 years and up to 4 years for victim 70 years old or above.

Elder Abuse with death: up to 5 years for the victim under 70 years and up to 7 years for victim 70 years old or above.

Elder Abuse second offense or subsequent offense: $2000 fines and up to 364 days of jail time in county jail.

Financial Abuse: up to $10, 000 in fines and up to 364 days in county jail depending on the amount of money or valuable.

Questions about elder abuse penalties under PC 368

Is elder abuse a felony or a misdemeanor in California?

It depends on the risk of harm. Penal Code section 368 makes the more serious tier of elder and dependent adult abuse a wobbler: when the conduct occurs under circumstances or conditions likely to produce great bodily harm or death, section 368(b)(1) lets prosecutors file it as a felony, punishable by two, three, or four years in state prison, or as a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 364 days in county jail and a fine of up to $6,000. When the circumstances are not likely to produce great bodily harm or death, section 368(c) makes the base charge a misdemeanor.

Do the penalties increase if the victim is 70 or older?

Yes. If the elder abuse causes great bodily injury, section 368(b)(2) adds an extra three years in state prison if the victim was under 70, or five years if the victim was 70 or older. If the abuse results in death, the added term is five years for a victim under 70 and seven years for a victim 70 or older. These are sentencing enhancements added on top of the underlying elder abuse sentence, not separate charges.

Is a caregiver who restrains an elder treated under this same statute?

Unlawfully restraining an elder or dependent adult by violence, menace, fraud, or deceit is charged as false imprisonment and sentenced under this elder abuse scheme rather than the general false imprisonment penalty. Our false imprisonment page explains how that charge otherwise works.

Available Defenses:

In our experience of successfully defending hundreds of elder abuse cases, we have almost seen it all. We know that many of the charges are completely baseless and are only intended to harm the defendant. We uncover the facts about the case and bring details that imply that there are not