False Imprisonment

What happens if you restrain someone from going out against his or her will? Or what happens if you lock your spouse in a room when he or she wants to go out? You may be charged with a criminal offense under PC 236 and PC 237. Whether you keep hold them for few minutes to some hours, you can be held accountable for false imprisonment of the victim. The act of restraining or holding the person when it does not reach the level of kidnapping is charged with the lesser crime of false imprisonment. The firm's guide to kidnapping charges explains when restraint crosses that line into the more serious offense.

Our law firm has been featured on

Fox NewsNBC NewsTIMEThe Wall Street JournalCBSThe New York TimesABCUnivisionLos Angeles TimesCNNMSNBC

David Chesley in the news

Select a photo to enlarge

If you are charged with violation of PC 236, you can be convicted of either a misdemeanor or a felony with a permanent criminal record which means the long lasting impact on your employment opportunities. Do not despair. Call the law office of David S. Chesley at (800) 755-5174 for a free consultation.

Definition of False Imprisonment

As defined in the PC 236, false imprisonment is an unlawful infringement of freedom of another person. In simplest terms, any confinement, restraining, or restricting someone at one place or to force him or her to go to the other place is false imprisonment in the eyes of the Californian criminal system.

Elements of Crime

To establish the charges of false imprisonment against a person, the prosecutor must prove the following things in front of the law.

To Prove a Misdemeanor

  • The defendant ‘willfully’ and ‘unlawfully’ held, restrained or confined the victim.
  • The defendant held, restrained or confined the person against his or her will.

To Prove a Felony

  • The defendant ‘willfully’ and ‘unlawfully’ held, restrained or confined the victim by using force or violence.
  • The defendant held, restrained or confined the person against his or her will by using force or violence.

Examples of False Imprisonment

The common examples of false imprisonment appear to be something like this,

  • Holding your spouse or cohabitant fro, walking out of the heated argument.
  • Restraining your spouse from leaving home after a fight.
  • Unlawfully forcing a customer to stay at the shop without any reasonable suspicion.
  • Forcing customer to go to the backside of the shop without reasonable suspicion.
  • Holding your boss/ co-worker in an office room at gunpoint.
  • Threatening to harm or injure another person if the other person leaves the room.
  • Restricting employees to one room for theft interview not allowing them to use the bathroom or make a phone call.

In the events when violence is used such as the use of a firearm or a knife to restrain the victim, it is charged as a felony. When the defendant involves minimal force such as holding a hand or blocking the door, it is often charged as a misdemeanor.

Penalties of False Imprisonment

You should not consider the charges of false imprisonment trivial. If convicted you can face thousands of dollars in fine, jail time in county jail and if you are convicted of a felony, you can face imprisonment in state prison. It depends on the seriousness of the crime, duration of restraining, and previous criminal record whether the charges are filed as felony or misdemeanor.

A caretaker accused of neglecting rather than confining an elder or dependent adult faces the separate felony-or-misdemeanor structure of the elder abuse statute, covered on our elder abuse page.

Importance of Consent

Consent is one of the most important factors in false imprisonment. If the customer or employee or the person gives the consent to be held or stopped, it cannot be charged as false imprisonment. For example, you asked the employee for written or verbal consent before holding them for theft interview; you cannot be charged under PC 236. If you took the permission of the customer before holding them for bag check, it is also not a violation of personal liberties.

Questions about a false imprisonment (PC 236) charge

What does “false imprisonment by violence” mean?

False imprisonment itself is defined in Penal Code section 236 as the unlawful violation of another person’s personal liberty. On its own, it is a misdemeanor under section 237(a), punishable by a fine of up to $1,000, up to 364 days in county jail, or both. The charge becomes a felony, with exposure to a term under Penal Code section 1170(h) - served in county jail for most defendants rather than state prison - only when the prosecution can show it was accomplished by violence, menace, fraud, or deceit, not by minimal physical restraint alone.

What is the difference between “violence” and “menace” in this charge?

Violence generally means physical force greater than what is reasonably necessary to restrain someone, while menace typically means a threat of harm, express or implied, that caused the other person to stay or go somewhere against their will. Fraud and deceit cover situations where someone was tricked into giving up their freedom of movement rather than physically forced. Any of these four methods can support the felony version of the charge, so a case built only around minor physical contact may not meet the standard the prosecution needs.

Is false imprisonment of an elderly person charged differently?

Yes. Section 237(b) specifically addresses false imprisonment of an elder or dependent adult accomplished by violence, menace, fraud, or deceit, and ties its punishment to the elder abuse sentencing scheme in Penal Code section 368(f) rather than the general false imprisonment penalty. Our elder abuse page explains how those penalties work.

Available Defenses in False Imprisonment

David S. Chesley’s law office has a team of defense attorneys that are known for their knowledge and experience in courthouses across California. With detailed analysis of the crime scene and the circumstances, we pick out available defenses and manipulate them in strong arguments. Some of the commonly available defenses in the cases of false imprisonment are,

Voluntary Presence: The person consented to the restraint or was not held against his or her will.

Lawful Detention: The defendant had reasonable suspicion against the victim to have committed a crime or to endanger himself. For example, you witness someone stealing from the shop; you confined that person to the shop until law enforcement officers came to the scene, it is lawful detention.